Revisiting four iconic photographers from the &rsquo;90s who reimagined the concept of family portraiture.

Family photos are some of our most precious possessions. Whether they are made to be seen or kept private, the material is as important to those captured as those it affects. Reviewing the cells of this social body, four particular photographers from the 1990s who questioned the format&rsquo;s rites, rules, and mechanisms come to mind. From <a href="https://kow-berlin.com/artists/clegg-guttmann" target="_blank" rel="noopener">Michael Clegg and Yair Martin Guttmann</a>, who distantly and meticulously photographed <a href="https://www.lofficielusa.com/fashion/influential-fashion-families-hermes-fendi" target="_blank" rel="noopener">power families</a>; to <a href="https://www.theguardian.com/film/2019/feb/23/richard-billingham-ray-and-liz-interview" target="_blank" rel="noopener">Richard Billingham</a>&rsquo;s spontaneous and dirty realism; the tenebrous Southern Gothic style of <a href="https://www.sallymann.com/" target="_blank" rel="noopener">Sally Mann</a>; or the sumptuously classic imagery by <a href="http://carriemaeweems.net/" target="_blank" rel="noopener">Carrie Mae Weems</a>; their bodies of work disclose the dynamics and complexities of family portraiture.
Beginning at the height of the U.S. stock market boom of the 1980s, Wall Street bankers had portraits taken for their annual reports in the tradition of 18th century Dutch paintings, in which the rising industrial bourgeoisie demanded to be immortalized. Influenced by this historical lineage during the decade obsessed with the image and a sense for conceptual irony, Clegg and Guttman emerged. The artist duo has operated a formal crossover between the borrowed classicism of Swiss watch ad campaigns and Anthony van Dyck canons, ultimately questioning the representations of power and the stratagems that constitute them. Presented in the 1987 exhibition Fake: A Meditation on Authenticity at the New Museum in New York City, curated by William Olander, their portraits highlight the family photograph as a weapon of a social game. Enthroned on the catalogue&rsquo;s cover, a work titled &ldquo;An American Family: A Rejected Commission&rdquo; looks as arrogant as it is sinister.

In the photograph, a family poses against a voluptuously obscure background with martial-looking figures emerging from the darkness of global finance. The parents sit at the base with an earthly confidence, while the children stand by, ready to take up the torch. The <a href="https://www.lofficielusa.com/art/fatherhood-contemporary-artists-parenting-kids" target="_blank" rel="noopener">father</a> is dazzled, the color of his Cifonelli tie already tarnished by his own mortality. The son, on the other hand, wears a tight smile that struggles to conceal a snide look inherited from his failed years at Bennington College (a time and place memorably depicted in Bret Easton Ellis&rsquo; The Rules of Attraction). At the center of the scene, the <a href="https://www.lofficielusa.com/fashion/mother-daughter-owned-fashion-brands" target="_blank" rel="noopener">mother</a> looks like the Duchess of Guermantes teleported in from the HBO series Succession. More than just the family, the photograph represents the social body; an aggregation of mutual interests, a pack that marks its territory through showmanship. The psychology of the individual becomes the attitude of a class. As its title indicates, the portrait was rejected by the commissioning clients.

In contrast to Clegg and Guttmann&rsquo;s acidic view of the ruling class, Richard Billingham presented intimate snapshots of his family when he was an art student in London. Titled Sensation, the show was organized by Charles Saatchi at the Royal Academy in 1997. Billingham&rsquo;s photography typically features his parents, Ray and Liz, and brother, Jason, in a decrepit flat on the outskirts of Birmingham in the north west of England. Taken mostly without his subjects&rsquo; attention, Billingham&rsquo;s shots capture an unpolished and brutal reality whose yellowed grain reinforces its expressiveness. Developed on inexpensive prints, the form marries the content and contributes to this diffused feeling of dirty realism. His <a href="https://www.lofficielusa.com/pop-culture/famous-celebrity-mother-daughter-duos" target="_blank" rel="noopener">mother</a> has <a href="https://www.lofficielusa.com/pop-culture/shocking-celebrity-tattoos-miley-cyrus-justin-bieber" target="_blank" rel="noopener">tattooed</a> arms and chain smokes cigarettes. His father is seemingly always drunk and haggard. Unemployed, Billingham&rsquo;s brother alleviates his boredom with hard drugs and Britpop. It&rsquo;s 1997, and England&rsquo;s disenfranchised are paying the price of eight years of Margaret Thatcher&rsquo;s economic policies. In the middle of the family&rsquo;s living room, a cat and dog make their way between the furniture where knick-knacks, jigsaw puzzles of exotic destinations never visited, carnivalesque Venetian masks, and empty beer bottles reside. The bodies are jarringly human: they scream, belch, laugh, ingest, exhale, and expel. One thinks of a bestiary: Billingham&rsquo;s small flat is a den or a lair where a family takes refuge from a hostile outside world. The spectator is confronted by an intimacy that is sometimes sad, burlesque, or embarrassing, but still caught in a game of promiscuity and emotional intensity.

More than just the family, the photograph represents the social body&hellip;a pack that marks its territory through showmanship.

The tenderness in Billingham&rsquo;s gaze is nevertheless not absent. Rather than an obvious affiliation with a post-punk aesthetic &agrave; la <a href="https://www.lofficielusa.com/fashion/supreme-taps-nan-goldin-for-their-latest-collaboaration" target="_blank" rel="noopener">Nan Goldin</a>, the photographs are instead inspired by British realism. Indeed, the photographer shares a taste for the representation of domestic ennui and proletarian realities with the Victorian painter Walter Sickert and the Camden Town Group. In a more contemporary way, it is English realist cinematography that comes to mind, like Bill Douglas&rsquo; autobiographical trilogy My Childhood, My Ain Folk, and My Way Home (or Ken Loach&rsquo;s dramas Kes or Riff-Raff). More recently, in 2018, Billingham adapted his tumultuous series of photographs into a film entitled <a href="https://www.nytimes.com/2019/07/09/movies/ray-and-liz-review.html" target="_blank" rel="noopener">Ray and Liz</a>, which won prizes at the Toronto and Locarno film festivals. As Brit-lit star Nick Hornby said of the artist&rsquo;s photographs: &ldquo;Even if they do nothing else, they do detain you.&rdquo;

Like Billingham, <a href="https://www.nytimes.com/2015/04/19/magazine/the-disturbing-photography-of-sally-mann.html" target="_blank" rel="noopener">Sally Mann</a> has ambivalence about the intimacy of her family. The American artist was another star photographer of the decade, and through her Immediate Family series&mdash;first exhibited at Philadelphia&rsquo;s Institute of Contemporary Art in 1992 and further published by Aperture&mdash;she invited the world into her summer home in rural Lexington, Virginia, where she photographed her children enjoying pastoral life: laughing, dancing, jumping, grabbing wild berries, hurting themselves, and even bleeding. These are original gestures that are marked by impermanence. Under the storm, the children become the actors of allegories; the smallest actions take on an antediluvian quality, as if they had existed for eternity. We feel the passage of time: these minute vibrations move us, unfolding through changes in light or temperature that affect both subjects and viewers. Moments of joy give way to more painful experiences, play to violence, discovery to fear, and we learn about death in spite of our own innocent natures. The purity of the device, its proximity with her children, is disarming in its nakedness and at the same time made nobly confusing by the breadth of her symbolism.
The black and white is magnetic and ethereal, reminiscent of the classic documentary photographs of the Great Depression, such as those by <a href="https://www.moma.org/artists/3373" target="_blank" rel="noopener">Dorothea Lange</a>. The density of the natural elements&mdash;the black river, the moist forest&mdash; give the photographs a romantic or even fantastic quality. More directly, it is the entire Southern Gothic universe that is summoned: the mixture of cruel violence and reassuring benevolence shown to the photographer&rsquo;s children coupled with a more symbolic scope. We are in the cradle of America, that of a new Eden, a territory of myth and haunted tales.

Another crucial landmark in matters of family portraiture in the &lsquo;90s is the sumptuous series of domestic photographs by American artist Carrie Mae Weems.&nbsp;<a href="https://carriemaeweems.net/galleries/kitchen-table.html" target="_blank" rel="noopener">The Kitchen Table Series</a> consists of 20 black-and-white photographs and 14 pieces of text written in third person of various scenarios depicting a woman&rsquo;s day in the kitchen. Rigorous and sober, all the photographs have a single light source illuminating from the ceiling, and are taken from the same angle at the end of the table. At once sanctuary and confessional, a refuge and a battlefield, the kitchen is an assigned and gendered space, but also the one where all negotiations take place. In what remains a Bildungsroman, we follow a woman embodied by Mae Weems through daily activities. She plays cards, engages in <a href="https://www.lofficielusa.com/politics-culture/who-was-florynce-flo-kennedy-black-feminist-activist" target="_blank" rel="noopener">political debates</a>, puts on makeup with her daughter, has dinner with her husband, and feeds a caged bird. There is a kind of choreography involved, in which the table becomes a domestic stage. This series is emphatically cinematographic, as if we are witnessing a framed shot&mdash;the place of the perceptible and the controllable&mdash;subject to whirlwinds provoked by external life, the counter-shot. Of her photographs, Mae Weems&rsquo; longtime friend Mike Kelley said: &ldquo;Her images are obviously constructed and don&rsquo;t represent themselves as being factual; rather, they have a mythic dimension that forces you to deal in a more complex way.&rdquo;

The Kitchen Table Series is an intimate odyssey that questions the power balance within a family and relationships. Despite the identifiable factual elements, Mae Weems&rsquo; photographs are shrouded in mystery. They are enigmatic scenarios; we never know if the situations will lead to a happy or sad outcome. It is all about the pleasure and terror of being at home. One is sometimes reminded of the Danish painter Vilhelm Hammersh&oslash;i&rsquo;s elegant grey paintings of women, alone, waiting in the darkness of their flats like Madame Bovary. Mae Weems&rsquo; photographs share the same tension between an almost anthropological gaze and a formal intensity, revealing the lyricism of everyday family existence between courage, modesty, and resignation.

Whether an object of power or a source of embarrassment, a happy memory or the subject of mourning, a doorway to intimacy or a means of resistance, the family portrait is one of photography&rsquo;s most classic formats. In a decade marked by a return to reality but also by the explosion of limits between public and private spheres, it ties us to a form of universality, the capture of the loved or hated one. It is no coincidence that in the classic photographic theory book Camera Lucida, author Roland Barthes&rsquo; entire demonstration revolves around an absent photograph, the most precious one, a family portrait&mdash;that of his missing mother.

”An American Family, A Rejected Commission,” 1987, by Clegg & Guttmann. Courtesy of the artist and Georg Kargl Fine Arts. 

Looking at the Legacy of '90s Family Portraiture

Tags

Related Articles

L'Officiel Art

What Fatherhood Means to 6 Contemporary Artists

Fashion

10 of Fashion's Most Influential Families

Fashion

Family Matters: 5 Chic Mother-Daughter Owned Fashion Brands

Recommended posts for you

Men's

Why Men Should Wear Small Watches: The Answer Is Paul Mescal

Fashion

See NYC's Most Exciting Store Openings in 2024

Fashion

L’HISTOIRE: Devon Aoki’s Nude Roberto Cavalli Dress in 2003

Pop culture

A Look Back at Young Joan Baez Through Iconic Photos

Travel & Living

Want the Ultimate Luxury Maldives Experience? Try This Lush Villa

Travel & Living

Experience Ultimate Luxury: Onefinestay’s Most Exquisite Stays and Dream Destinations

Travel & Living

How a Subreddit Helped Me Plan My Perfect Manhattan Wedding

Travel & Living

Brazil's Tania Bulhões Brings Its Luxury Tableware to the US With a Ritzy Dinner Party